Eureka!

After two days of unsuccessfully trying every suggestion I found on removing tarnish from and polishing silver I was feeling desperate and defeated. I had moved on to cleaning the black marks off my wall when inspiration hit. With nothing to lose, I tried my Mr. Clean Magic Eraser. I'm not sure why I was surprised because it'd never let me know before, but, to my amazement, it took off the tarnish and polished the silver effortlessly. I didn't even have to rub. It just took the lightest wipe! Perhaps magic does exist.